Showing posts with label Non-Fiction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Non-Fiction. Show all posts

Friday, 5 March 2010

Book Review: Eating Animals - Jonathan Safran Foer

Read: January 2010

Eating Animals in one tweet-sized chunk:
Eating Animals is about the stories we tell about the food we eat. But also the gaps between the stories we tell and the stories as they actually are.

“Stories about food are stories about us - our history and our values.”

When I sat down to write this review I did so with 16 pages of notes and ambitions to compose a review that would change the eating habits of every person who read it. Only such lofty goals, I felt, could do justice to a book that casts the debate around the meat industry in a fresh light.

But what I soon realised as I considered how to achieve this gargantuan feat, was that the brilliance of Eating Animals is the extraordinary realism Foer injects into the debate. His master-stroke is to get away from the all-or-nothing vegetarian versus carnivore debate in favour of a third way, a way that promotes a reduction in our collective consumption of meat to a level that is conducive to stable and lasting farming practices. This is not a fundamentalist case for vegetarianism, or a moralistic case against eating meat per se, but an exploration of why the choices we make about what we eat matter – to ourselves, the animals we do or don’t eat, the planet, and the lives of all those who inhabit it.

Those who have enjoyed either of Foer’s sublime novels – Everything is Illuminated and Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close – will find the same inventiveness is at play here, alongside a familiar appreciation that what matters most is not facts and figures but the stories that surround them. He lets a factory farmer speak for himself, devotes an entire chapter to a debate between a farmer, his vegetarian wife, and a vegan PETA activist. He has an inherent understanding that there is no such thing as unequivocal truth, merely lots of different stories that collectively make up a whole.

Eating Animals is about the stories we tell about the food we eat. It is about their importance to our communal experiences of eating, our cultural ways of life. But it is also about the gaps between the stories we tell ourselves and the stories as they actually are. And it is about the stories we want to tell about ourselves in the future.

These stories begin with Foer himself. Having spent the first twenty-six years of his life disliking animals and oscillating between vegetarian and omnivore, between feeling guilty about eating animals and savouring the taste and smell of meat, the prospect of becoming a father made him reconsider the person he wanted to be. Taking his cue from Michael Pollan’s assertion in The Omnivore’s Dilemma that “eating industrial meat takes an almost heroic act of not knowing,” and faced with the responsibility of deciding what to feed someone more important than himself, Foer set out to understand what sort of repercussions the decision to eat meat had. But what started as a curious bit of research soon grew into a mission to expose factory farming and the culture of cheap food that drives it. He joins an animal rights activist in breaking into a factory farm under cover of darkness, and what troubles him most is not the horrific living conditions of the birds, though they are bad enough, but the secrecy, the locked doors and hi-tec surveillance.

“In the three years I will spend immersed in animal agriculture, nothing will unsettle me more than the locked doors. Nothing will better capture the whole sad business of factory farming. And nothing will more strongly convince me to write this book.”

Above all else Eating Animals is a bid to burst open that secrecy and end the whole barbaric practice of factory farming once and for all. Part investigative journalism, part scientific study, and told through a variety of literary mediums, it is difficult not to be convinced by the passion and conviction of his arguments and the panache with which he conveys them. Of all the arguments in the book it is the assertion that what we chose to eat matters that reverberates longest. He recounts a powerful conversation with his grandmother about how she survived the holocaust:

“The worst it got was near the end. A lot of people died right at the end and I didn’t know if I could make it another day. A farmer, a Russian, God bless him, he saw my condition, and he went into his house and came out with a piece of meat for me.”
“He saved your life.”
“I didn’t eat it.”
“You didn’t eat it?”
“It was pork. I wouldn’t eat pork.”
“Why?”
“What do you mean why?”
“What, because it wasn’t kosher?”
“Of course.”
“But not even to save your life?”
“If nothing matters, there’s nothing to save.”

One must make choices based on our own conscience, and Foer never deviates from this central assertion. However, that doesn’t mean that he doesn’t do everything in his power to shape our consciences. Much of Eating Animals makes uncomfortable reading. He tells of turkeys genetically modified to the point of being unable to reproduce sexually, to a state where there are virtually none left in America that could survive in the wild. “What we do to living turkeys,” he asserts, “is just about as bad as anything humans have ever done to any animal in the history of the world.”

He tells of the pigs slaughtered in stages, of cesspools filled with animal excrement, and the often-overlooked seafood industry’s mind-boggling war on the seas. He breaks down statistics into conceivable metaphors. At one point he asks the reader to imagine being served a plate of sushi that also holds all the animals that were killed for that one serving, concluding that “the plate might have to be five feet across.” Another chapter begins with its title - ‘Influence / Speechlessness’ - repeated roughly 840 times over five pages. Why? Because “on average, Americans eat the equivalent of 21,000 entire animals in a lifetime – one animal for every letter on the last five pages.”

Some consider this sort of approach glib and distracting, but it is this exuberance to communicate in a variety of ways that has always made Foer’s work so engaging, and it is as powerful here as ever it has been.

Not all the book is made up of tales of animal abuse, though. Far from it. Much time is devoted to the environmental degradation that results from factory farming. “Just as nothing we do has the direct potential to cause nearly as much animal suffering as eating meat, no daily choice that we make has a greater impact on the environment.” He explains how factory farming is implicated in the spread of global pandemic illnesses such as bird flu, how it produces terrifying quantities of waste which has no sewerage system through which to be disposed, and how meat is injected with so many hormones that it is strengthening the resistance of viruses to antibiotics and thereby damaging our health. His argument is that cheap meat is a false economy as factory farms do not pay for the mess they create, that they pass on all the associated costs of environmental clean-up and health-care to taxpayers without taking responsibility for either their actions or the consequences.

It would be difficult not to reach the conclusion, as he does, that industrial factory farming is a horrendous blight on our world that cannot even begin to be excused by the cheap meat it produces. While it is important to recognise that Eating Animals deals almost exclusively with the American industry and that the situation there is more extreme than in the EU, the picture he draws is reflected to a lesser or greater degree in every meat industry in the western world. It would be a travesty if the focus on the American system were taken to give readers reason to adopt the sort of arrogant superiority that so often underpins our reactions toward America. After all, the UK has some of the cheapest food prices in the world and those savings have to come from somewhere.

The problem Foer quickly encounters is that we consume too much meat - about 150 times more chicken than we did eighty years ago. And that sort of production is only possible through factory farming.

“We shouldn’t kid ourselves about the number of ethical eating options available to most of us. There isn’t enough nonfactory chicken produced in America to feed the population of Staten Island and not enough nonfactory pork to serve New York City, let alone the country. Ethical meat is a promissory note, not a reality. Any ethical-meat advocate who is serious is going to be eating a lot of vegetarian fare.”

Foer spends an inordinate amount of time searching for an ‘ethical farm,’ a farm whose meat he would be happy to feed his children. Though he finds better farms whose work is based on traditional animal husbandry and organic rearing, he still witnesses what he considers barbaric and unnecessary practices such as branding and concludes that there is no such thing as humane farming methods. This is the closest he comes to stating openly that he believes eating animals to be wrong. Yet still, he doesn’t say ‘don’t eat meat’ but rather, ‘eat less meat’. He separates his personal decision to become a committed vegetarianism from a universal demand that others follow. Because of this many hard-line vegans have criticised Eating Animals for its refusal to explicitly support universal vegetarianism. He is wise enough to know that an absolutist argument of this kind would be counter-productive. So he couches his argument in storytelling, in a journey of discovery. He pitches this book not at a distant utopian future of universal vegetarianism but a first-step incremental reduction in meat consumption for all

Eating Animals is a rallying call to unite in opposition to the factory farming method of meat production. Yet it is typical of the book that Foer doesn’t sugar-coat this message in moral absolutism, but rather a return to stories.

“To give up the taste of sushi or roasted chicken is a loss that extends beyond giving up a pleasurable eating experience. Changing what we eat and letting tastes fade from memory creates a kind of cultural loss, a forgetting. But perhaps this kind of forgetfulness is worth accepting – even worth cultivating (forgetting, too, can be cultivated). To remember animals and my concern for their wellbeing, I may need to lose certain tastes and find other handles for the memories that they once helped me carry.”

As a reviewer I am guilty of describing books as ‘must read’ far more often than is strictly true. Indeed, it is arguable whether any fiction is ever must-read. However, if there is ever a book that warrants the moniker then it is Eating Animals or another book on the ethical and practical questions raised by the food we eat. Aside sleep and death, there is nothing that can be said to unite the entire global population as eating does. What we eat, and the impact it has on the lives we live and the world around us, is a fundamental question of our existence.

Eating Animals ends with its author hosting a meat-free Thanksgiving for family and the acceptance that they will need to develop new stories for this new diet. But, he contends, that is a small price to pay for not living with the shame of supporting such a profoundly abhorrent meat production system. During the course of his journey he repeatedly returns to an emblematic story about Franz Kafka staring into a fish tank and, on seeing his own reflection mingling with the animals he once ate, saying “Now at least I can look at you in peace.”

Life is about recognising the person you are and the person you want to be. It is about making decisions based on knowledge rather than routine. Without ever being overly preachy, Eating Animals asks us all to stare into a fish tank, to see ourselves reflected, and to decide what stories we wish to tell in the future.

9 out of 10

Eating Animals is published in the UK by Hamish Hamilton, March 2010. ISBN: 9780241143933. 352pp

Tuesday, 2 March 2010

Book Review: 84 Charing Cross Road - Helene Hanff


To celebrate the 200th review on Books, Time, and Silence, I will be re-posting 10 of my favourite reviews. 

On day 8 it is the correspondence between a New York writer and London bookseller that make up 84 Charing Cross Road by Helene Hanff.

Read: November 2008

84 Charing Cross Road
in tweet-sized chunk:
A book lovers dream, 84 Charing Cross Road chronicles one of the most enduring long-distance friendships to be found in literature.

When Helene Hanff sat down at her typewriter on October 5th, 1949 and typed off a purchase order to a small antiquarian bookshop in London, little could she know that she was about to be drawn into an intercontinental friendship that would last decades and chronicle both her life, and the lives of those she corresponded with. But that is what happened. The ensuing friendship between herself – a free-spirited and self-educated New York writer with ‘an antiquarian taste in books’ – and Frank Doel – a reserved bookseller in post-war Britain – was to last for more than twenty years, and capture much of their different personalities, as well as the character of their cities, separated by a wide ocean, and a common language.

Their relationship catches something of the age. It is 1949 and Britain is still recovering from war, with rationing and reconstruction the order of the day, and stoic survival the dominant mood. Frank Doel embodies the Britain of strict social and moral codes, stiff upper lip professionalism, and courteous detachment. Against this Helene is fiery and abrasive, a no-nonsense New Yorker full of witty sarcasm and little respect for personal boundaries. She sees Frank as delightfully representative of a romantic literary past in which John Donne attends Trinity College, Samuel Pepys is chased around the bedroom by his wife brandishing a red-hot poker, and books are printed in beautifully bound, gold edged hardbacks.

Theirs is a deep friendship, but not the love story some suggest. For Helene the love affair is with ‘the England of English literature’ which Frank so helpfully lays out for her, while to him she is an taste of excitement from across the Atlantic, brash and fun in a way post war Britain was not. This intercontinental friendship is charming. You read along enraptured; aware of how privileged you are to be granted such intimate insight into two lives, adopting their friendship almost as if it were your own. You smile along with Helene when she is sent into ecstasy by the arrival of a first edition of John Newman’s Idea of a University, and with Frank when a parcel of tinned food (near impossible to get due to rationing) arrives at the bookshop. When she asks him to root for the Brooklyn Dodgers, he responds by asking her to ‘give a few cheers for THE SPURS’. She vents with fury at the destruction of a book used for packaging, and he travels to sales disbanding once great estates to see if he can find any good books in their libraries.

For a books aficionado, this is an absolute joy. There is so much to learn about classic literature, the lives of great writers, and the history of the book trade. Helene Hanff’s self-taught learning is impressive. At one point she describes her early readings, and the way she consumed the annuls of literature one step at a time, from Milton’s Paradise Lost, to Arther Quiller-Couch’s lectures, to The Bible. This is a book chock full of life and energy and perfect characterisation.

And yet between the lines there is so much sadness. Time passes silently, with so much happening in each of their lives that is never spoken about. Invisibly, they grow older and have adventures and experiences we never hear about, tragic events strike, time passes; life goes on away from our prying eyes. At times months and even years go by without a letter, what happens in these years a mystery. It is difficult not to wish for so much more than the 99 pages. The more you read, the more you want to read, and all this life lived between the lines on the page is so close and yet so utterly unreachable that you yearn for more.

But the passage of time is reassuring as well, for time does not pass for Helene and Frank. Outside their correspondence, the world continues to turn, but nothing affects their camaraderie. Like the English literature whose history they are each so steeped in, they remain untouched, and when you finish the last letter, one of the joys is that they remain before you for a long time, like long lost friends who you will never forget. And in this beautiful Virago celebration edition, we also get The Duchess of Bloomsbury, a diary of Helene's eventual trip to London in promotion of 84 Charing Cross Road. It offers a beautiful counterpoint to the longing of her correspondence, and a fascinating portrait of the real London, warts and all, even through the eyes of a lifelong anglophile such as Helene. I love 84 Charing Cross Road, it is a wonderfully enchanting book and I cannot recommend it highly enough.

9 out of 10

Saturday, 11 April 2009

In Cold Blood - Truman Capote


Read: August 2006

This is part murder mystery, part psychological suspense thriller with an intricately unravelling plot that would leave fans of Michael Connelly or Patricia Cornwell quivering for more. But it is not fiction. Truman Capote literally created a genre with this book, the true account of a quadruple murder in Kansas In another author’s hand, this subject could degenerate into a red-blooded witch-hunt, but Truman Capote is too good for that. He is the king of sympathy, where others see good and bad, he sees individuals and intertwining stories of tragedy. He is able to seamlessly blend touchable characters with adroit observation’s and brilliant one-liners. And it is neither macabre, nor gruesome, but rather a glorious investigation into human weakness. Read this book, it is hard to describe why it is so good, but it is.


7 out of 10


Friday, 10 April 2009

Flat Earth News - Nick Davies


Read: January 2008

“Journalist used to question the reasons for war and expose abuse of power. Now, like toothless babies, they suckle on the sugary teat of misinformation and poop it into the diaper we call the six o’clock news.”
Kent Brockman, TV Newsreader, The Simpsons

Watching the BBC news last week I was confronted with an example of outrageously lazy journalism. In a report about mistreatment of horses and farming for horsemeat a reporter spent the first minute or so traipsing through the field with a horse, introducing it, grooming it. Then he said: “Of course, this horse wasn’t farmed for meat, but he might have been!” or words to that effect.

I mean, what sort of pathetic, pointless, lazy journalism is that? What state has our media got to when this didn’t even surprise me; just elicited a brief snort of derision. That it is a cartoon newsreader on The Simpsons who enunciates the abysmal state of our media most effectively demonstrates what a farcical situation we are in. For humour is the only way to really tell a sad story. Flat Earth News seeks to tackle this very issue, and it is timely indeed.

Award-winning journalist Nick Davies has worked in the media for over twenty years, but following the debacle of the weapons of mass destruction in Iraq story, he decided to turn his skills to his own profession, to discover just how so many people could have been so very wrong. The result is Flat Earth News, a damning indictment of the state of our media.

There are some dramatic revelations. Notably the prestigious Sunday newspaper which allowed the CIA and MI6 to plant fiction in its columns and the newspapers who pay cash bribes to bent detectives. But away from these dramatic headlines and the exposé’s which will steal all the column inches, there is a more worrying analysis, an intrinsic weakness in the structure and culture of journalism. It is not that there is a government conspiracy, or big business planting stories in the papers, or journalists deliberately misleading the public, it is far less deliberate than that, an insidious inherent production floor which prevents the functions of journalism working as they should. News factories operating like sweatshops with a focus on speed and profitability above all else, particularly journalistic integrity.

This focus on profits has led to a dramatic decline in the number of journalistic employees, with the result that fewer and fewer journalists are being asked to write an ever greater number of stories more quickly than ever before. So facts are not checked as they should be, questions are not asked, investigation not undertaken. Research found that of the big five, (supposedly) respectable newspapers (Times, Telegraph, Mail, Guardian, Independent) only 12% of their stories in a given fortnight were their own work and that only 12% of their key facts were being checked. So essentially, the basic background was being undertaken on less that one in eight stories. Increasingly journalists are using news agencies and merely paraphrasing them into reports without once subjecting their contents to the rigours of truth.

And what is the problem with this I hear you say? News agencies do not have claims to journalism, they exist to report what is said accurately and without questioning whether the person saying something has any qualifications to be saying it or whether what they are saying is even correct. As such, they do only a small aspect of a reporters duty. And if no-one is doing the other aspects, then the result is unlikely to be very accurate. Still going to buy your ‘newspaper’ tomorrow?

Although he doesn’t say so explicitly, the conjecture of his argument is that the media is becoming a vast gossip column. It seeks to be the biggest, the fastest, the most up to date with whatever is happening in the world, but in doing so it pays less attention to being the truest. In the rush to get its conjecture out and fill the airwaves or papers with comment on breaking news stories, any old idea is thrust out there, the more controversial the better. And when the dust has settled and the time for in depth analysis has come, those original conjectures have become so embedded in the public psyche that almost nothing can be done to challenge their perceived truthfulness.

“This is Flat Earth news. A story appears to be true. It is widely accepted as true. It becomes heresy to suggest that it is not true – even if it is riddled with falsehood, distortion and propaganda.”
"The Earth is flat."
Anybody, anywhere, until somebody checked.

Examples of this kind of news story are many, the Millenium Bug, ‘Get Tough’ policing, nuclear power, heroin; in each of these the perceived notions of fact are actually far from the truth. The Millennium Bug, for instance, began life with one scientist trying to bring the issue to the attention of his local media, but within a year it had been picked up across the world, with few journalists attempting to discover the actual scale of the threat, a threat which was, in reality, far over predicted. Any competent media system could have identified it as only semi-credible, and yet it built up from a few press releases to such hysteria that it was heralded by many as a potential apocalypse. And once news gets to this size, it becomes impossible to contradict, because the fallacy is so much more powerful than the non-event truth ever could be.

It is a similar story with New York’s fabled ‘get tough’ policing during the 1980’s. Despite rampant public perception that New York was cleaned up due to a series of hard policies and putting more policemen on patrol, this was, in fact, only a small aspect of it. Indeed, Davies argues that almost all evidence suggests that putting ‘bobby’s on the beat’ is the least productive of all policing methods. Yet to suggest this in the modern climate amounts to heresy.

And it is not just right-wing ideas which are attacked. Davies argues that the left has seriously misreported the threat of nuclear power, particularly the environmental and health results of a meltdown. In fact, far from the catastrophic wasteland Chernobyl has been heralded as, it is suggested that the actual scale of disease in its residents, even fifteen years later, was but a tiny fraction of the absurd estimates some commentators use. That without arguing Chernobul to be anything other than a disaster, the disaster was predominantly caused by the explosion itself, its very immediate aftermath, and the worldwide fear it produced, rather than the long lasting radiation which is but a fraction of the threat to health it has been reported as. Because although it appears to be similar to the nuclear bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the level of radiation produced in the creation of nuclear power is actually only a fraction of its destructive equivalent. Indeed, it is argued that coal miners and pilots are exposed to more radiation than your average nuclear power worker. As Nick Davies says; “I found this very difficult to accept.” Yet accept he does, for all the evidence points in that direction.

“This is Flat Earth news. A story appears to be true. It is widely accepted as true. It becomes heresy to suggest that it is not true – even if it is riddled with falsehood, distortion and propaganda.”

This is Flat Earth news, and a whole swathe of people talking as though they are experts about things they know next to nothing about, reporting the dramatic, the exciting, not the factual. And after all this, what does Nick Davies think can be done to arrest this worrying trend? Precisely nothing.

“I’m afraid that I think the truth is that, in trying to expose the weakness of the media, I am taking a snapshot of a cancer. Maybe it helps a little to be able to see the illness. At least that way we know in theory what the cure might be. Bit I fear the illness is terminal.”

I did not need any reason to distrust our media more. I don’t watch the news or read newspapers precisely because I find it impossible to trust anything they say. Watching the news is like watching a film, only without the time and effort spent on doing it well. It is nice to have the facts to back this notion up but to think that the illness is so deeply routed and insidious makes me both very worried and very angry.

Still going to buy your newspaper tomorrow morning? Still going to turn on the six o’clock news tonight? If so, just remember, there is probably as much fact in your bedside novel as there is in that news story. Because at least fiction seeks only to convey the general impression, the idea of something, the experience of it. Whereas what is news without truth? Kent Brockman, over to you:

“Journalist used to question the reasons for war and expose abuse of power. Now, like toothless babies, they suckle on the sugary teat of misinformation and poop it into the diaper we call the six o’clock news.”

Well said, Kent. Well said.


7.5 out of 10

The Songlines - Bruce Chatwin


Read: July 2008

In 1987, Bruce Chatwin published The Songlines. It went straight to number one and spent the next eleven months residing in the Sunday Times top ten. Part fictionalised travelogue, part metaphysical exploration of the nomadic lifestyle, Chatwin writes with real passion and conviction about one of the most fascinating and romantic of Aboriginal mythologies. The Songlines stretch across Australia, invisible pathways which criss-cross the land telling stories of ancestral journeys and the creation of the terrain itself. The Songlines charts Bruce Chatwin’s journey to unravel their meanings, and understand their significance.

We join Bruce as he arrives in Alice Springs. In an art shop there he comes across the commonplace perception of Aboriginal culture: the white westerner buying a piece of Aboriginal artwork to take home and demonstrate their romantic anthropological experience. But Bruce is having none of that. He meets a Russian/Australian man named Arkady who works for the railway company, and joins him as he journeys through various tribal lands, meeting elders and trying to find a way of building a railway which does not cross the songlines. Over the course of the journey, Bruce speaks with all sorts of Aborigines, as well as many of the people who work with them. The picture he builds of their amazing songlines both debunks some of the new age mysticism that surrounds them, and at the same time manages to make them even more remarkable than you could ever have imagined.

So that is where we are half way through the book. So far, so good. In fact, so far, great! The tale is involving, packed full of fascinating information, and human stories. But then Bruce Chatwin decides to tie in the lessons he has learnt about the songlines with his grandiose notions of the importance of nomadic lifestyle to the human psyche. So suddenly we get some sort of unedited slush pile of all the notes he has taken over the years for a book he never published. From a fascinating travel journal, the book becomes a dense socio-philosophical treatise on the glories of travel.

“Our nature lies in movement, complete calm is death.”
Pascal, Pensees

“To live in one land, is captivitie,
To Runne all countries, a wild roguery”
John Donne, Third Elegie

“He who does no travel does not know the value of men.”
Moorish Proverb

“This life is a hospital in which each sick man is possessed by a desire to change beds. One would prefer to suffer by the stove. Another believes he would recover if he sat by the window.
I think I would be happy in that place I happen not to be, and this question of moving house is the subject of a perpetual dialogue I have with my soul.”
Baudelaire, ‘Any Where Out of this World!’

There are some fascinating quotes, in fact there are hundreds of quotes gleamed from across history. These sort of musings infuse the notebooks completely. Through a mixture of cultural anthropology, personal experience, and philosophy, Chatwin advances the argument that man originated as a nomad, and that is how he is happiest. Just as babies are calmed by the motion of their parents’ walk, so the human psyche at all ages, finds contentment and peace in movement. And this movement, not just in Australia but across the world, has left its mark on the earth, in stories and songs and culture. It is our collective history, and a lesson in our future.

However, his theories do go on. When I picked up The Songlines, this is not what I really expected. It is hard work at times, and the logic of the argument isn’t completely convincing. But no-one can deny the passion of his argument, nor the energy with which he conveys it.

The Songlines is a celebration of travel and the constant search for experience, and beauty, and meaning. If you have the travel bug, then you will love this book, it is an absolute must read. Or if, like me, you don’t but are fascinated by the almost vicelike grip it holds on some people, then it is an equally fascinating investigation into the mindset of travelling. The Songlines is a book that many, many people have absolutely loved. And with a beautiful set of newly issued jackets, Bruce Chatwin is ready for a whole new generation of readers to discover him anew.

Not just a fascinating investigation into the Aboriginal Songlines, this is Bruce Chatwin’s treatise on the imperative to travel which is common across humankind. Passionately argued and packed full of great quotes, this is one of the biggest selling travel books of all time.


7 out of 10