10 out of 10
Friday, 29 October 2010
Book Review: Matilda by Roald Dahl
10 out of 10
Tuesday, 24 August 2010
Book Review: We by Yevgeny Zamyatin
We in one tweet-sized chunk:
A compelling dystopian story of love and rebellion with a mathematical style all of its own creation.
Yevgeny Zamyatin completed We in 1921, only for it to gain the dubious honour of becoming the first book to be banned by Glavlit, the newly created Soviet censors. Yet while it remained unpublished in the USSR until Glasnost, a manuscript escaped and has had a lasting influence on literature ever since. It is considered one of the first dystopian novels, and George Orwell read and reviewed a French translation only eight months before starting Nineteen Eighty-Four. There are many parallels between the two: for Big Brother, We has the Benefactor, for the telescreen, Zamyatin creates the Table, a formula that constructs every second of every citizens time. Similar parallels are noticeable with Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World, though Huxley apparently hadn’t read it before publishing in 1932. Yet regardless of any comparisons, We is valuable in its own right: a compelling story of love and rebellion with a mathematical prose all of its own creation.
“Of course, it's revolution. Why not?"
“Because there can't be a revolution. Our revolution was the last and there can never be another. Everybody knows that.”
“My dear, you're a mathematician: tell me, which is the last number?”
“But that's absurd. Numbers are infinite. There can't be a last one.”
“Then why do you talk about the last revolution?”
Friday, 20 August 2010
Book Review: Master Georgie by Beryl Bainbridge
Master Georgie in one tweet-sized chunk:
Short and apparently simple, Master Georgie is an enjoyable snapshot of lives and the Crimean War.
It is a rare delight to encounter a book of such apparent simplicity as Master Georgie. The narration – split between three voices – is compelling and smooth, the prose wonderfully uncluttered. It is overloaded neither with explicit themes or complicated ideas. There is no sense of a writer trying to be clever. Master Georgie is storytelling of the finest order.
And yet I use the phrase ‘apparent simplicity’ advisedly, for the simplicity of style masks a cunningly composed narrative which questions how one can ever know something simply by looking at it. In Master Georgie, Beryl Bainbridge confronts the reader with an oddly compelling statement: you cannot know these characters.
When war breaks out in the Crimea George Hardy, surgeon and photographer, sets off to provide whatever services he can offer in support of the British effort. With him travel his adoptive sister Myrtle, amateur geologist Dr Potter and photographer’s assistant and fire-eater Pompey Jones. The narration is split between them, starting in the cold back streets of 19th century Liverpool, travelling through sweltering Constantinople and on to the battlefields of the Crimea. As each seeks to shed light on Master Georgie (as Myrtle terms him) a picture begins to develop of everyone but him. He remains the dark spot on the plate.
The Crimean War was the first to be extensively documented by photography and one gets the impression that Bainbridge spent a great deal of time searching for inspiration for her characters by looking at these pictures, only to come up with more questions than answers. That is how the book reads: a snapshot of a long dead, anonymous person who can never be resurrected, not even through literature. Master Georgie is all about what lurks beneath the surface of a photograph: the context, facets of themselves people choose to hide from the world, the misinterpretations that people ascribe to surface images. At one point a fellow character enquires as to why Myrtle often looks sad. “It’s the way I am on the outside”, she replies. “Inside, I assure you I’m quite happy.” This seems to sum up Master Georgie nicely.
There is an element of satire here, too. There are two targets for this: specifically the bombast of Tennyson’s ‘Charge of the Light Brigade’ and generally those who gallantly march off at the first hint of war assuming victory. It reminded me very much of The Siege of Krishnapur by J.G. Farrell with its portrayal of out of place Britishness, a pompous sense of worth that is never fully punctured, even while confronted by death, disease and defeat. There are some absurdly funny moments. The wealthy British bring trunk -loads of possessions and are accompanied as far as the Constantinople by their spouses and children as though for a bit of a summer jaunt. There is a funny scene when, having arrived in Constantinople, they go to the opera only for it to descend into a brawl over a perceived indiscretion towards Myrtle.
The satire is not biting though, and surrounding it is a tender portrayal of life, war and the consequences of our actions. Like the best war books, one comes away feeling that it was all so bloody pointless.
Yet none of this is to say that Master Georgie is an easy book. It is slippery, never quite giving the reader what one wants or expects. The drama is quiet, unassuming. Some of the supposedly dramatic aspects – particularly the shared and mysterious guilt the synopsis promises – didn’t really resonate with me at all. The prime feeling I came away with was puzzlement: I knew I had enjoyed the prose and the journey without really engaging with any of the characters; without being able to identify why. Others I know have reacted to it with utter indifference. Yet the fact remains that I enjoyed reading it, and it continues to challenge and interest me a month later. This was my first Beryl Bainbridge novel but I’m certainly going to read more by her in the coming months.
7 out of 10
Abacus, 1998, 9780349111698, 212pp
Further Reviews:
Dovegreyreader
Book Page
Salon
New York Times
Amazon
Wikipedia
Tuesday, 30 June 2009
Skellig - David Almond
Read: April 2009
Skellig in one Tweet-sized chunk:
Skellig is pretty much the perfect novel.
Michael has just moved to a new house. His baby sister is clinging to life in hospital having been born prematurely. His parents are exhausted with worry. He just wants things to go back to normal. Then one day he wanders into the crumbling old garage and finds an old man lying amongst the spiders' webs behind an old tea chest. At first he seems dead, but he is not. Michael brings him food – 27 and 53 from the local Chinese takeaway and a bottle of brown ale, “food of the Gods” as the man describes them – and starts to visit him regularly. And together with his new neighbour Mina, they hatch a plan to carry him out into the light and help him live once again.
There is not much more to say about Skellig really, other than that it is virtually the perfect book. David Almond's prose is lyrically delightful, easy to read, and laden with exquisite tenderness and real warmth. It is a beautifully story, universally appealing, and with an inspiring plot which will not only bring a smile to your face but put a little tear to your eye as well. Partly fable for the childhood we all dream of having and partly lesson on the beauty of life, it is a book which everyone should read.
8.5 out of 10
Sunday, 12 April 2009
Case Histories - Kate Atkinson
Read: April 2009
Darkly comic and well characterised, Case Histories introduces Jackson Brodie as he seeks to bring order to the world one case at a time.
Jackson Brodie is a private investigator with a conscience. Some even say he's “the last good man left.” Recently divorced, with failing health, he accepts cases without concern for whether he will be paid, and spends long hours visiting with his motley assortment of clients. For him, life is an eternal balancing act between the lost and found, debits and credits in a great accountancy exercise in human suffering. He has morose tastes in music – Emmylou Harris, Trisha Yearwood, Gillian Welch – old singers who “understand pain.” He dreams of emigrating to a new life in France, of keeping his daughter Marlee safe from the horrors of the world. But none of this is going to happen, not while an old colonial relic like Binky Rain is calling him at all hours to help find her cats. And, on top of everything else, it appears that someone is trying to kill him...
Case Histories is a finely characterised detective novel in which three old, unsolved cases are resurrected and gradually come together thanks to Jackson's hard work and empathetic ability. It is an exciting, complex mystery. It is also darkly humorous, set in the completely ridiculous world of Cambridge where characters are overcome with libido on a drive to Diss, Italian teenagers on their bicycles cause traffic hazards, and everyone working in customer service seems to be Australian. Kate Atkinson brings a healthy dose of scepticism to her narrative, filling it with melodrama, absurdity, and a sense that everything is far too normal. Most notable of all, Case Histories is shot through with a kind of simple, human morality not often found in high-posturing literature. Money is worthless, time is irrelevant, all that seems to matter is doing ones duty and trying to help those who need it in any way possible. It is a joy to find a book with so little pretension.
The prose however is a little clunky. It is instructive rather than demonstrative, packed with redundant description. The authorial standpoint is too distant from the characters, standing back from the action and describing everything the character sees, thinks, and does. Many sentences begin “Jackson thought....,” or “Jackson felt...” or “It seemed to Jackson...,” instead of cutting out these redundant openings and getting straight to the point of describing what it is he actually thinks, feels and sees. I wanted to get out a nice thick-nibbed red pen and edit the whole book down into a more stylishly flowing pace.
However, I have talked to others who absolutely loved the prose and cannot understand these criticisms. The structure and pace of the novel is intricate, conversational, and enjoyable so perhaps these stylistic questions don't even matter. I guess it all comes down to a question of taste: I have always been concerned, above all else, with style and narrative flow, often to the detriment of other factors.
More to the point, these problems, if indeed they are problems, are largely overcome by the books many virtues. The characterisation is first rate. Each character is a complex entity, seeing the world through their own eyes and understanding the same events in slightly differing ways. They try to be good and successful, but cannot help but see the worst in themselves. Bravado is delightfully absent. They have that delightful ability not to be able to see the good in themselves. And sometimes their perceptions are flawed.
This all makes Case Histories fantastically ambiguous. There are big gaps in the plot where things happen which the reader is not told about, only left to surmise from what is not said. Case Histories is basically written as a series of snapshots of different conversations and ruminations, which interweave and overlap each other, gradually building a complex double (more like quintuple) helix of different lives lived in the face of extraordinary misfortune.
As Jackson stumbles between cases, seemingly unable to remain detached from the people he is working with, long kept secrets are divulged and characters begin to step out of the shade of history and live their lives completely once more. Perhaps things happen a little too easily, perhaps these long forgotten crimes fall into place a little too neatly, but that is not too much of a negative. The solutions are never as simple or obvious as they promise to be. And the point of Case Histories is that it is about looking at the people behind the crimes; their lives, their hopes and fears. Answers are reached, not by shouting or bullying, not through pressurising or bribing, but by sitting down quietly with those involved and talking to them. It is a thoroughly human book, full of morality and good intentions; of trying to be the best you can be even when that is not the person you ever expected you would become.
7 out of 10
Saturday, 11 April 2009
A History of the World in 10 1/2 Chapters - Julian Barnes
Read: May 2006
8 out of 10
Time's Arrow: or The Nature of the Offence - Martin Amis
There is nothing original about writing life backwards. Yet it is a mark of Martin Amis’s subtle humour that he is able to say something truly fascinating about human nature. This is the story of Todd T. Friendly, former Nazi Medical Executioner and now all-round American nice-guy. By situating the narrator within Todd’s body but not actually part of his mind, the narrator is able to take a step back from the action, to observe the absurdities of life, whether backwards or forwards. This book also plays with your consciousness, blurring your interaction with the world. Whenever I stopped reading, I found myself completely unsure which way round things should happen: should I get in or out of the bath next? How many books can alter the state of your mind, even for a few moments? Martin Amis is toying with your psyche, few author have the playful sense of humour to do this with such an apparently serious subject.
8 out of 10
The Handmaid's Tale - Margaret Atwood
Read: May 2007
Gilead is a totalitarian state, a religious autocracy in which women have been subjugated by a return to traditional values and the men all seem to occupy highly suspicious roles within the state secret service. It is a devoutly Christian state, which has perverted biblical theology to support its highly racist and sexist social engineering, a reaction against the liberal permissiveness of the latter twentieth century. Many would say it is a highly probable state which has grown from the current rise on Neo Conservative values and ideas. Many feminists have heralded it as a masterpiece in gender studies, a horrific future grown from a divisive present. But to me, I don’t know why, it just seemed highly improbable. For one thing, no-one likes it.
As a work of fiction it is a powerful read with some absolutely delightful passages. Much of the future language mirrors that of George Orwell’s 1984 unspeak and as a tale of total repression it is successful in that we come to sympathise and empathise with the existence – life is not the word – of Offred, and to a lesser extent many of the other characters. Atwood does well to make Offred a rounded character and because we are witness to some of her weaknesses and vices as well as her victimhood she becomes very real, the sort of person you might meet any day in the street. We spend the entire book living inside her head, and this is something that Margaret Atwood achieves brilliantly. The style of prose is disjointed, and some may find the abruptly curtailed and abbreviated sentences difficult to follow but at the same time this gives the story an air of authenticity, a sense of the self censorship with which the handmaid is speaking.
What spoils this book for me a little is the ‘historical notes’ section at the end, a quasi historical attempt to offer context to the novel and provide answers to the questions the novel rises. This post-modernist ending infuriated me and I would encourage everyone out there to ignore it, DO NOT READ IT! One of the things I liked most about this novel was the way in which both the historical and geographical setting were blurred. Aside from a few opaque references to technology, this could be a story taking place anywhere at any time. This fictitiousness made it much more powerful to me, I loved the befuddled atmosphere, as if it was the dark essence of a fairytale gone wrong. The red cloaks of the handmaid’s recall Little Red Riding Hood perfectly.
Margaret Atwood seems to be an almost universally respected and acclaimed novelist, beloved across the world as one of Canada’s leading exports. She is in the mould of Toni Morrison and Dorris Lessing, one of the leading female novelists around today. Indeed, The Handmaid’s Tale is similar in many ways to Dorris Lessing’s apocalyptic future novel ‘Mara and Dann’. This is the first of her novels that I have read but with a consistently popular backlist beckoning she is an author to really get stuck into.
7.5 out of 10
Friday, 10 April 2009
The Fall - Albert Camus
Read: December 2007
Jean-Baptiste Clamence spends his days in an Amsterdam bar dispensing existential advice to anyone who will listen. Over several nights he tells his story to a chance acquaintance, pouring forth a tale of huge success and a catastrophic, self imposed fall from grace.
In Camus’ way, the story is dense and complex, full of obscure references and philosophical concepts. Addressing the reader as his chance acquaintance, Jean-Baptiste regales us with his views on the universal human condition, the inherent hypocrisies and hollowness of his success and the forbidden knowledge which, once glimpsed, transformed his life forever.
Though never the easiest of writers, Camus is intelligent and what he says matters. If you like your fiction laced with a huge dollop of philosophy then this is the book for you.
5 out of 10
The House of the Spirits - Isabel Allende
Read: April 2008 The House of Spirits is, in short, exceptional. It tells the story of the “house on the corner,” the family residence of Esteban Trueba, under whose roof more than half a century of Chilean history is played out. Under that roof four generations of the Trueba family live their lives: weddings, marriages, fortunes made and lost, tragedies and success stories, intrigue, controversy, fallings out, violence, growth, acceptance, transformation. The plot is crammed with action, intrigue and revolution, all in less than 500 pages.
Often when a book is short on dialogue, with 50 page opening chapters of dense long paragraphs it can be difficult to get into. But not The House of Spirits. Within 5 pages I was engrossed in the lives of these fantastic characters: Esteban Trueba who goes off to make his fortune in the gold mines so that he can return and marry Rosa, a beautiful mermaid-like being who walks through life in a daydream; her introverted psychic sister Clara whose big dog Barrabas is her only friend; their eccentric uncle Marcos with a whole trunk full of interesting and exotic books, Esteban’s sister Ferula who sacrifices her life to care for their sick mother. Within this chapter there is an accidental death, marriage, cruel persecution, grand evening soirée’s and poverty stricken homelessness, grief and jubilation and a momentous first flight in an aeroplane. The House Of Spirits covers the whole spectrum of emotion and action. Its plot flows sweetly from one adventure to another, like a grand river tour through all the worlds most magnificent cities in history one after the other, on and on forever.
Every character is drawn with a loving, human touch, they are all capable of moments of pathetic petulance and the grandest gestures of generosity, and they constantly evolve and surprise us. To achieve this evolution over the course of their lives is a supreme achievement, I cannot laud Allende’s composition highly enough.
And despite tackling emotive, controversial issues, Allende retains complete control of her characters and plot. No political ideal is ever supported in favour of another, no character uniformly good or homogeneously evil. We feel as much for Esteban Trueba when the Socialist revolution confiscates his property and workers as we do for those self same workers when they lose their revolution in the military coup. Even while we mourn the passing of the old order, we celebrate the excitement and ideas of the socialists. And even the military junta has its benefits – clean streets, beautiful parks, easy money making – alongside its less savoury acts of persecution, torture and habitual murder. And the characters are the same: we are never left wholly despising the philandering Trueba who rapes his peasants and has a temper that threatens to destroy everything in his vicinity, just as even the mystical Clara or the willing sufferer Ferula have their human failings as well.
And I absolutely love the delicate narrative stance. It is such an achievement to be able to transform from third to first person seamlessly, without disrupting the flow, to have the impression that one character is the narrator throughout when it turns out at the end it is someone else altogether. There are so many clever aspects of this novel but their brilliantly accomplished realisation makes them invisible. At no time do they intrude upon a novel which is a great epic story, well written and thoroughly intriguing. I love it. You should read it now.
9 out of 10
The Master and Margarita - Mikhail Bulgakov

Friday, 3 October 2008
Beside the Ocean of Time - George McKay Brown

7.5 out of 10
Beside the Ocean of Time is one of the most beguiling books you are likely to read. Like the thick, rolling ocean beside which it is set, this is a book which will sweep you up in its swell and carry you away to great battles and exciting adventures without you ever realising you have left the comfort of your armchair. You may not grasp how much you love it, but you are thoroughly, wonderfully, engrossed.
It is the early 20th Century and life has changed very little on the small Orkney island of Norday for hundreds of years. The same families do the same jobs they always have, as fishermen, and farmers, and craftsmen; the men drink in the one pub, the woman wish they wasted less money on alcohol, they all shop together at the only shop on the island.
But Thorfinn Ragnarson, a young boy growing up on the island, does not quite fit in. He is an idle daydreamer, so much so that the book opens with this immortal sentence, “Of all the lazy useless boys who ever went to Norday school, the laziest and most useless was Thorfinn Ragnarson.” He has no interest in taking over the family business, nor settling down to the simple life of the island. Instead, he spends his days recreating great battles and grand adventures from the island’s lore. Through his hungry eyes we travel through time to meet with invading forces landing on the shores, threatened islanders hiding in a narrow keep, soldiers fighting against the English king and country. And Thorfinn is in all of these, ever present in the story of the island.
But the present is a time of cataclysmic upheavals in the world, and not even the people of Norday can hope to escape its transformations. War is coming, and the tranquil island will never be the same again.
Beside the Ocean of Time is a beautiful, simple tale of island life and those who inhabit it. It is a rewarding and lyrical read, packed full of mythology and adventure, and a healthy dollop of magical realist seal people to boot! Books this simple leave me thoroughly in awe, you can hear the wind howling through the thin walls and the rain pelting the land; you can feel the sea whip wildly against the shore, and the history hang amid the mist hovering over the island. It is not bleak – no, far from it! – Beside the Ocean of Time is rich and powerful and enthralling. Just buy it, I cannot imagine anyone not being won over to its simple, dreamy, story.


