Showing posts with label Booker Prize. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Booker Prize. Show all posts

Sunday, 14 October 2012

Book Review: Swimming Home by Deborah Levy



Original jacket
'When Kitty Finch took her hand off the steering wheel and told him she loved him, he no longer knew if she was threatening him or having a conversation.'

For lovers of witty, arresting, unsettling prose – prose that reads like the best poetry - Swimming Home is a rare delight. The marriage of unashamedly literary and eminently readable books has become a hallmark of And Other Stories (the independent publishers of this novel) and Swimming Home is another masterpiece. From this first sentence, which introduces the feel of lives running out of control, of impending danger and lust and transformation, Deborah Levy produces a short page-turning cliff-hanger of rare brilliance.

On the surface, Swimming Home is riddled with clichés in both characters and plot – it is essentially a family drama populated by wealthy, artistically inclined characters whose lives are falling apart until the arrival of a mysterious stranger who throws everything into chaos – yet Levy takes these familiar elements and crafts them into something new. There is barely a sentence that didn’t produce some physical reaction in me as I read it. The writing is a firework spectacular. You feel the words, engage with them emotionally and sensually as well as intellectually. They rise around you, come alive in your mind, transport you to new and unexpected places. Deborah Levy creates a hallucinatory dreamscape of colours and symbols and metaphors, a psychoanalysts playground where every word, image, and object is significant and post-Freudian ideas of sex and death drive the plot forward. Swimming Home is a concentrated study of psychological states, of perceptions of depression and the impact diagnosis and medication can have on lives.

The Jacobs – celebrated poet Joe, war-correspondent Isobel, and their 14 year-old daughter only-daughter Nina – are holidaying in the south of France with Isobel’s friend Laura and her husband Mitchell. The atmosphere is taught and competitive, barely buried marital strife, infidelity, financial concerns, and work-life inequalities rife amongst the adults. It looks like being a long summer, particularly for Nina. That is, until they wake one morning to find Kitty Finch floating naked in their pool, red hair and green nails, arms pointing ahead like a starfish, like a superhero. Marshall mistakes her for a bear. She has confused her booking dates. Isobel invites her to stay. The mermaid steps out of the water to disrupt their plans and guide them through their summer. She is a poet and she is quirky, fun, psychologically unstable. She quickly becomes the centrifugal force around whom the other characters circle.

'Standing next to Kitty Finch was like being near a cork that had just popped out of a bottle. The first pop when gasses seem to escape and everything is sprinkled for one second with something intoxicating.'

Yet Kitty is no femme fatal; she is as vulnerable as they are, entranced by the poet she has read and the words he has given her. She and Joe are united by their experience of depression and antidepressants. ‘Give me your history and I will give you something to take it away’, he has written about his experiences of medication as a teenager. There is a theme here, between knowledge and forgetting; the amnesia that Joe and Kitty resent is contrasted with longing to forget that Isobel as a war-correspondent exposed to knowledge of the bleakest things in life dreams of. The reader quickly realises that there will be things learned on this holiday that will change things for everyone.

Levy borrows a technique from Emily Bronte in telling a tale about women through the façade of a male central character. The women are not always likeable, but they are powerful, compelling and determine their own stories, act in their own ways, without translation by male sensibility. Gender roles aren’t simple. On the surface, Joe is a typically serially unfaithful bipolar poet, yet he also plays the role of sole parent to Nina when Isobel is away. The women are enigmatic, the scope of behaviours available to them broader than in many novels.

Readers will feel all sorts of artistic spirits in the background – Ali Smith’s The Accidental, Arthur Miller plays, van Gogh paintings, Wuthering Heights, Rebecca were just some of those that arose for me – but Swimming Home owes its compelling brilliance to the fearsome intellect and lyrical prowess of its author.  There is little to criticise here. That it was turned down by a host of mainstream publishers for being too literary for a tough economic climate says much about the uncertain, fearful, artistically confused publishing world of the moment, and their – sometimes - lack of faith in readers. I'm delighted that the Booker Prize has reflected the rise of exciting small publishers in its shortlist for 2012.

Swimming Home is an elliptical novel. Time shifts and disorientates, narrative focus moves between characters. Scenes and motifs repeat and evolve. ‘Life is only worth living because we hope it will get better and we'll all get home safely,’ Kitty says on multiple occasions. ‘But you did not get home safely. You did not get home at all.’

Liminality dominates. Swimming Home is perilous, teetering on the brink of dream and wakefulness, of metaphor and literal, of medicated health and unmedicated madness, of childhood and adulthood, of life and death. Water is both a refuge and a prison. Dive in, submerge yourself, and feel it surround you.

Swimming Home was originally published by And Other Stories in October 2011. ISBN 9781908276025. 
Since Booker longlisting, it has been republished to meet demand by And Other Stories and Faber & Faber. ISBN 9780571299607, 176pp.

Sunday, 14 November 2010

Book Review: The Finkler Question by Howard Jacobson

Read: October-November 2010 (not completed)


Reviewed for Borewrimo, a month in which I aim to experiment with the form and purpose of book reviewing by writing 50,000 words of book reviews as short stories.

She begins in a fit of exuberance.

The Booker winner has just been announced and it comes as a complete surprise to her. She shouldn’t be surprised – she’s never once accurately predicted the winner – but she is. It was the only one she thought couldn’t possibly win.
Inevitably, she is delighted: it feels like a personal gift from the judges. Yesterday she would never have considered reading it; now she cannot wait to start.

She jogs home through crisply deserted streets. Stars visible in the clear autumn sky, cars keeping watch over the deserted urban landscape. Her head buzzes from too much elderflower cider and socialising. She cannot wait to be alone with that book in her hands. It is the lover she longs to undress.

As she takes it gently from the bag her nails trace its pages. She is ready for a life-changing experience.

***

Sometimes it is difficult to stay awake.

It becomes apparent after only a few short pages that this is not to be the literary panacea she imagined. It’s clunky in her hands and on her mind. They do not move gracefully together as lovers should, but fumble against each other without connection or intimacy.

Days later, she wonders why she started this. She should be more discerning, more circumspect. She should take other people’s advice and test the water first: read a page or two first, see whether the plot synopsis draws her in. Had she done so it would never have come to this. There were warning signs blazoned across the inside jacket: an overly long blurb that seemed to be attempting the exaggerated absurd without managing to make even the corner of her mouth twitch into a smile.

Had she only read page 100 she would have found this passage, so convoluted it sums up everything she comes to dislike about the book, and never read any further.

“Finkler, as it happened, was well aware of his old friend’s sons and felt warmly disposed to them, not impossibly because he was Treslove’s rival in fatherhood and unclehood as well as in everything else, and wanted to be seen to be making up to the boys for what their real father hadn’t given them. Making up the them and giving them a higher standard to judge by. Alf was the one he knew better, on account of an incident at the Grand Hotel in Eastbourne – the gist of it being that Finkler had calculated on the Grand being a reliably romantic and discreet place to take a woman for a Friday night and Saturday morning – seagulls outside the windows and the other guests being too old to be able to place him or to do anything about it if they had – but he hadn’t calculated on finding Alf playing the piano during dinner.”

But that is not her way. She is all or nothing. A book is a projection of who she might be rather than who she is. She is interested in the story of why she has picked up a book perhaps more than the book itself. And so she finds herself in situations like this: stretched out in bed in the company of three aging men who neither excite, make her laugh, or even elicit sympathy.

The Finker Question is middle-aged male literature at its worst, a tawdry affair comprising little more than ambivalent sex and an absurd attempt by the protagonist Julian Teslove to manufacture a Jewish identity for himself. It is a biting satire about Jewishness – The Finkler Question of the title being Treslove’s private way of saying The Jewish Question – and society’s obsession with stereotyping certain groups with certain traits, but it’s too absurd to be meaningful and too flippant to find amusing.

Enjoying a leisurely walk home late one night, Julian Treslove is attacked, shoved against a shop window and mugged. Shocked by this unprovoked violence, his shame is further exacerbated by the discovery that his assailant is female. But as the days pass by he becomes troubled by another element of the attack. Somewhere in the back of his mind, he is sure she called him a Jew. A Jew! Could this have been a mistakenly anti-Semitic attack? He finds himself associating this violence with the violence he feels Jews must have suffered throughout history, and comes to identify with them.

Two things trouble her about this premise. Firstly, she cannot help but feel that the shock engendered by the mugger being a woman is symptomatic of the insipid maleness of the entire book. This makes her uneasy and ostracises her, not as a woman but as a human being who doesn’t understand the need to categorise men and women so starkly.

The second thing that troubles her is more practical: she knows nothing about Jewishness. Other than references to global political issues such as the Israel-Palestine conflict she feels herself swimming against the tide. On every page, she imagines there to be some kind of Jewish joke being made, or else some subtle Jewish commentary, but it goes over her head. For all she can see, it is essentially about Treslove’s desire to find belonging in an otherwise disassociated life. In an intellectual sort of way, he’s sympathetic, as are his recently widowed friends. But it goes no further than this. She cannot care for them, cannot even whip-up disinterest.

She doesn’t hate it. She certainly doesn’t love it. But ambivalence is the worst response one can have to a book. She can barely be bothered to pick it up. Night after night she lies cradling it in her hands. Night after night she falls asleep mid-sentence. On not one of the twenty-four nights that she tosses and turns does she manage more than fifteen pages before drifting into peaceful sleep. Most nights it is more like five.

She tells herself:
“I’m overworked. By the time I get to bed I’m so tired I can barely keep my eyes open. It’s not the book. It’s me.”

She also tells herself:
“If reading were easy then it wouldn’t be so rewarding.”

She always finishes books. In her entire life she can only think of only three she has stopped before the end. And one of those was only because another book came along that she wanted to read more. Only this year she ploughed through 200 mind-numbingly dull pages of Gone with the Wind to find she could no-longer put it down. The memory of this keeps her returning to Treslove night after night in the hope that love will blossom from disinterest.

She reminds herself that it is only by finishing the book that she is able to say whether she liked it or not. It is only by reading the final word that she can make sense of what has preceded it. And yet. Doesn’t that suggest that reading should be utilitarian? Doesn’t that create the impression that reading is about the end rather than the means, thus denying the tenet she holds most dearly: reading for the enjoyment of reading.

She should stop and read something else. But she cannot let go. To stop feels like denying herself the chance to understand, to square the circle and make sense of it all.

So she ploughs on.

***

Her life has not been without trauma. She spent her teenage years watching on as others fell in and out of love, getting close to people she longed to know. Once, aged fourteen she joined a group of bullies in the homophobic abuse a lapsed friend. The memory of that day will never be forgotten. Another time she opened up to her parents and now cannot get over how vulnerable she feels around them, how much their caring eyes haunt her. And then of course, earlier this year, she found out she probably couldn’t have children.
Perhaps none of these equates to the trauma of being mugged by a woman, or suspecting it to be an anti-Semitic attack. She could not say. But her reaction to everything that takes place in The Finkler Question can be summed up in the shrug of her too heavy shoulders.

And then, one day, she finds she no longer cares. Like a tired elastic band her patience has been stretched too thin and breaks without whiplash. She doesn’t pick it up again

That it saps her love of reading until there is nothing left for a while feels like the biggest trauma of all. For weeks she does not start another book, finds herself doing anything but making time for reading.
It is not the books fault and neither is it hers. Sometimes relationships don’t work out the way we wish them to.

Next time, she says, I’ll be more careful about what I choose to read.

But what one month of disappointment destroyed, it takes barely 10 minutes in a bookshop to rebuild. And before she knows it, she’s careering off into another relationship without a care in the world.

The Finkler Question is published by Bloomsbury (307pp, ISBN: 9781408808870, £18.99)

Tuesday, 9 February 2010

Challenge: Booker Prize


The aim of this challenge is continue progressing through the annuls of Booker history until I have read every winner and as many of the shortlisted books as possible.

Those books I've read are in bold and those I've reviewed linked through. 



1969
Winner
Something to Answer For - P H Newby
Shortlist
 
Figures in a LandscapeBarry England
The Impossible ObjectNicholas Mosley
The Nice and the GoodIris Murdoch
The Public ImageMuriel Spark
From Scenes Like These – G M Williams

197O
Winner
The Elected Member - Bernice Rubens
Shortlist
 
John Brown’s Body - A L Barker
Eva Trout - Elizabeth Bowen
Bruno’s Dream - Iris Murdoch
Mrs Eckdorf in O’Neill’s Hotel - William Trevor
The Conjunction - T W Wheeler

The Lost Booker
Winner
Troubles - JG Farrell
Shortlist
The Birds on the Trees by Nina Bawden
The Bay of Noon by Shirley Hazzard
Fire From Heaven by Mary Renault
The Driver's Seat by Muriel Spark
The Vivisector by Patrick White

1971
Winner
In a Free State - V S Naipaul
Shortlist
The Big Chapel - Thomas Kilroy
Briefing for a Descent into Hell - Doris Lessing
St Urbain’s Horseman - Mordecai Richler
Goshawk Squadron - Derek Robinson
Mrs Palfrey at the Claremont - Elizabeth Taylor

1972
Winner
G - John Berger
Shortlist
Bird of Night - Susan Hill
The Chant of Jimmy Blacksmith - Thomas Keneally
Pasmore - David Storey

1973
Winner
The Siege of Krishnapur - J G Farrell
Shortlist
The Dressmaker - Beryl Bainbridge
The Green Equinox - Elizabeth Mavor
The Black Prince - Iris Murdoch

1974
Winners
The Conservationist - Nadine Gordimer  
Holiday - Stanley Middleton
Shortlist
Ending Up - Kingsley Amis
The Bottle Factory Outing - Beryl Bainbridge
In Their Wisdom - C P Snow

1975
Winner
Heat and Dust - Ruth Prawer Jhabvala
Shortlist
Gossip from the Forest - Thomas Keneally

1976
Winner
Saville - David Storey
Shortlist
An Instant in the Wind - André Brink
Rising - R C Hutchinson
The Doctor’s Wife - Brian Moore
King Fisher Lives - Julian Rathbone
The Children of Dynmouth - William Trevor

1977
Winner
Staying On - Paul Scott
Shortlist
Peter Smart’s Confessions - Paul Bailey
Great Granny Webster - Caroline Blackwood
Shadows on our Skin - Jennifer Johnston
The Road to Lichfield - Penelope Lively
Quartet in Autumn - Barbara Pym

1978
Winner
The Sea, the Sea - Iris Murdoch
Shortlist
Jake’s Thing - Kingsley Amis
Rumours of Rain - André Brink
The Bookshop - Penelope Fitzgerald
God on the Rocks - Jane Gardam
A Five-Year Sentence - Bernice Rubens

1979
Winner
Offshore - Penelope Fitzgerald
Shortlist
Confederates - Thomas Keneally
A Bend in the River - V S Naipaul
Joseph - Julian Rathbone
Praxis - Fay Weldon

198O
Winner
Rites of Passage - William Golding
Shortlist
Earthly Powers - Anthony Burgess
Clear Light of Day - Anita Desai
The Beggar Maid - Alice Munro
No Country for Young Men - Julia O’Faolain
Pascali’s Island - Barry Unsworth
A Month in the Country - J L Carr

1981
Winner
Midnight’s Children - Salman Rushdie
Shortlisted
Good Behaviour - Molly Keane
The Sirian Experiments - Doris Lessing
The Comfort of Strangers - Ian McEwan
Rhine Journey - Ann Schlee
Loitering with Intent - Muriel Spark
The White Hotel - D M Thomas

1982
Winner
Schindler’s Ark - Thomas Keneally
Shortlist
Silence among the Weapons - John Arden
An Ice-Cream War - William Boyd
Constance or Solitary Practices - Lawrence Durrell
The 27th Kingdom - Alice Thomas Ellis
Sour Sweet - Timothy Mo

1983
Winner
Life and Times of Michael K - J M Coetzee
Shortlist
Rates of Exchange - Malcolm Bradbury
Flying to Nowhere - John Fuller
The Illusionist - Anita Mason
Shame - Salman Rushdie
Waterland - Graham Swift

1984
Winner
Hotel du Lac - Anita Brookner
Shortlist
Empire of the Sun - J G Ballard
Flaubert’s Parrot - Julian Barnes
In Custody - Anita Desai
According to Mark - Penelope Lively
Small World - David Lodge

1985
Winner
The Bone People - Keri Hulme
Shortlist
Illywhacker - Peter Carey
The Battle of Pollocks Crossing - J L Carr
The Good Terrorist - Doris Lessing
Last Letters from Hav - Jan Morris
The Good Apprentice - Iris Murdoch

1986
Winner
The Old Devils - Kingsley Amis
Shortlist
The Handmaid’s Tale - Margaret Atwood
Gabriel’s Lament - Paul Bailey
What’s Bred in the Bone - Robertson Davies
An Insular Possession - Timothy Mo

1987
Winner
Moon Tiger - Penelope Lively
Shortlist
Anthills of the Savannah - Chinua Achebe
Chatterton - Peter Ackroyd
Circles of Deceit - Nina Bawden
The Colour of Blood - Brian Moore
The Book and the Brotherhood - Iris Murdoch

1988
Winner
Oscar and Lucinda - Peter Carey 
Shortlist
Utz - Bruce Chatwin
The Beginning of Spring - Penelope Fitzgerald
Nice Work - David Lodge
The Satanic Verses - Salman Rushdie
The Lost Father - Marina Warner

1989
Winner
The Remains of the Day - Kazuo Ishiguro
Shortlist
Cat’s Eye - Margaret Atwood
The Book of Evidence - John Banville
Jigsaw - Sybille Bedford
A Disaffection - James Kelman
Restoration - Rose Tremain

199O
Winner
Possession - A S Byatt
Shortlist
An Awfully Big Adventure - Beryl Bainbridge
The Gate of Angels - Penelope Fitzgerald
Amongst Women - John McGahern
Lies of Silence - Brian Moore
Gursky Was Here - Mordecai Richler Solomon

1991
Winner
The Famished Road - Ben Okri
Shortlist
Time’s Arrow - Martin Amis
The Van - Roddy Doyle
Such a Long Journey - Rohinton Mistry
The Redundancy of Courage - Timothy Mo
Reading Turgenev (from Two Lives) - William Trevor

1992
Winners
The English Patient - Michael Ondaatje 
Sacred Hunger - Barry Unsworth
Shortlist
Serenity House - Christopher Hope
The Butcher Boy - Patrick McCabe
Black Dogs - Ian McEwan
Daughters of the House - Michèle Roberts

1993
Winner
Paddy Clarke Ha Ha Ha - Roddy Doyle
Shortlist
Under the Frog - Tibor Fischer
Scar Tissue - Michael Ignatieff
Remembering Babylon - David Malouf
Crossing the River - Caryl Phillips
The Stone Diaries - Carol Shields

1994
Winner
How Late It Was, How Late - James Kelman
Shortlist
Reef - Romesh Gunesekera
Paradise - Abdulrazak Gurnah
The Folding Star - Alan Hollinghurst
Beside the Ocean of Time - George Mackay Brown
Knowledge of Angels - Jill Paton Walsh

1995
Winner
The Ghost Road - Pat Barker
Shortlist
In Every Face I Meet - Justin Cartwright
The Moor’s Last Sigh - Salman Rushdie
Morality Play - Barry Unsworth
The Riders - Tim Winton

1996
Winner
Last Orders - Graham Swift
Shortlist
Alias Grace - Margaret Atwood
Every Man for Himself - Beryl Bainbridge
Reading in the Dark - Seamus Deane
The Orchard on Fire - Shena Mackay
A Fine Balance - Rohinton Mistry

1997
Winner
The God of Small Things - Arundhati Roy
Shortlist
Quarantine - Jim Crace
The Underground Man - Mick Jackson
Grace Notes - Bernard MacLaverty
Europa - Tim Parks
The Essence of the Thing - Madeleine St John

1998
Winner
Amsterdam - Ian McEwan
Shortlist
Master Georgie - Beryl Bainbridge
England England - Julian Barnes
The Industry of Souls - Martin Booth
Breakfast on Pluto - Patrick McCabe
The Restraint of Beasts - Magnus Mills

1999
Winner
Disgrace - J M Coetzee
Shortlist
Fasting, Feasting - Anita Desai
Headlong - Michael Frayn
Our Fathers - Andrew O’Hagan
The Map of Love - Ahdaf Soueif
The Blackwater Lightship - Colm Tóibín

2OOO
Winner
The Blind Assassin - Margaret Atwood
Shortlist
The Hiding Place - Trezza Azzopardi
The Keepers of Truth - Michael Collins
When we were Orphans - Kazuo Ishiguro
English Passengers - Matthew Kneale
The Deposition of Father McGreevy - Brian O’Doherty

2OO1
Winner
True History of the Kelly Gang - Peter Carey
Shortlist
Atonement - Ian McEwan
Oxygen - Andrew Miller
number9dream - David Mitchell
The Dark Room - Rachel Seiffert
Hotel World - Ali Smith

2OO2
Winner
Life of Pi - Yann Martel
Shortlist
Family Matters - Rohinton Mistry
Unless - Carol Shields
The Story of Lucy Gault - William Trevor
Fingersmith - Sarah Waters
Dirt Music - Tim Winton

2OO3
Winner
Vernon God Little - DBC Pierre
Shortlist
Brick Lane - Monica Ali
Oryx and Crake - Margaret Atwood
The Good Doctor - Damon Galgut
Notes on a Scandal - Zoë Heller
Astonishing Splashes of Colour - Clare Morrall

2OO4
Winner
The Line of Beauty - Alan Hollinghurst
Shortlist
Bitter Fruit - Achmat Dangor
The Electric Michelangelo - Sarah Hall
Cloud Atlas - David Mitchell
The Master - Colm Toibin
I’ll go to Bed at Noon - Gerard Woodward

2OO5
Winner
The Sea - John Banville
Shortlist
Arthur and George - Julian Barnes
A Long, Long Way - Sebastian Barry
Never Let Me Go - Kazuo Ishiguro
The Accidental - Ali Smith
On Beauty - Zadie Smith

2OO6
Winner
The Inheritance of Loss - Kiran Desai
Shortlist
The Secret River - Kate Grenville
Carry Me Down - M J Hyland
In the Country of Men - Hisham Matar 
Mother’s Milk - Edward St Aubyn
The Night Watch - Sarah Waters

2OO7
Winner
The Gathering - Anne Enright
Shortlist
Darkmans - Nicola Barker
The Reluctant Fundamentalist - Mohsin Hamid
Mister Pip - Lloyd Jones
On Chesil Beach - Ian McEwan
Animal’s People - Indra Sinha

2OO8
Winner
The White Tiger - Aravind Adiga
Shortlist
The Secret Scripture - Sebastian Barry
Sea of Poppies - Amitav Ghosh
The Clothes on Their Backs - Linda Grant
The Northern Clemency - Philip Hensher
A Fraction of the Whole - Steve Toltz

2009
Winner
Wolf HallHilary Mantel
Shortlist
The Children's BookA S Byatt
Summertime J M Coetzee
The Quickening MazeAdam Foulds
The Glass RoomSimon Mawer
The Little StrangerSarah Waters

2010
Winner
The Finkler Question - Howard Jacobson
Shortlist
Parrot and Oliver in America - Peter Carey
Room - Emma Donoghue
In a Strange Room - Damon Galgut
The Long Song - Andrea Levy
C - Tom McCarthy

2011
Winner
The Sense of an Ending - Julian Barnes
Shortlist
Jamrach's Menagerie - Carol Birch
The Sisters Brothers - Patrick deWitt
Half Blood Blues - Esi Edugyan
Pigeon English - Stephen Kelman
Snowdrops - AD Miller

2012
Winner
Bring up the Bodies - Hilary Mantel
Shortlist 
The Garden of Evening Mists - Tan Twan Eng
Swimming Home - Deborah Levy
The Lighthouse - Alison Moore
Umbrella - Will Self
Narcopolis - Jeet Thayil

2013
Winner
The Luminaries - Eleanor Catton
Shortlist 
We Need New Names - NoViolet Bulawayo
Harvest - Jim Crace
The Lowland - Jhumpa Lahiri
A Tale for the Time Being - Ruth Ozeki
The Testament of Mary - Colm Toibin

Friday, 10 April 2009

Siege of Krishnapur - J.G. Farrell

Read: July 2008

Voted by the good people of a Scottish village as their favourite of the Best of Booker shortlist, The Siege of Krishnapur is J.G. Farrell’s humorous take on the British Empire in India, 1860’s style.

After years of global supremacy, the age of Britain’s unrivalled Empire is coming to an end. The Indians are finding their voice, and a series of mutinies have broken out in small cantonments. Small and isolated, Krishnapur could be next. How do we know? Because chapattis have begun to appear all over the place, in collections of three. No-one knows exactly why, or what it means. But to the Collector, obsessed with the demonstration of human potential at the Great Exhibition, it spells disaster. It is an example of the new speed of communication between people hostile to British rule, their organisation, and impending threat.

First of all he is mocked. People whisper that senility is claiming him. But soon his fears are proved correct. And as the Sepoys close in on Krishnapur, the British are forced to retreat to the Collector’s residency and build their fortifications. But they are a ramshackle bunch of administrators, retired servicemen, women and children; against the organised enemy they stand no chance. So, with falling rations, awful sanitation, and no contact with the outside world, they set themselves to wait out the siege until someone comes to rescue them. Yet with resolute determination and imperial arrogance the soldiers just about manage to repel the attacks in their makeshift, stumbling sort of way. But as the months pass by, more and more is sacrificed to defend both the lives of the people living within the compound, and the British way of life itself. But if help doesn’t arrive soon, they are doomed.

The Siege of Krishnapur is witty, intelligent at interesting. There is a fascinating battle between the two doctors, one a quiet young Scottish physician; the other a superb orator, confident, learned, absolutely convinced of his methods. When an epidemic of cholera breaks out the two are brought into conflict for the hearts and minds of the people, and the validity of their scientific methods questioned. The people of Krishnapur take sides, following like sheep with wilful abandon, transforming their loyalties at the flick of a switch. They carry cards indicating which doctor they wish to treat them, and often these cards demonstrate that they have switched allegiances regularly. Old orators may rule the roost, but faced with life and death it is practical results which will judge who is correct.

And for the Collector there is an even greater test: will his treasured new technology be able to save their lives?

There is one great problem with this book, however. At no point in the plot did I really feel involved in the action. There are various characters and they are involved in some pretty hairy situations, but to be honest, I didn’t really care whether they survived or not. There is the Collector, who is reasonably interesting, a young lad named Fleury who is wet as a fish, a deluded and arrogant doctor, another quiet and reasonable doctor, a committed but out-of-touch reverend, and a bunch of other people with generic names such as The Magistrate. Half the time, I wasn’t even sure who was who! Many say this is a great, exciting novel. But to be honest, I found it pretty slow going. In my opinion it doesn’t matter whether a book is intelligent and witty, if it doesn’t have a narrative which compels you to read on, then it will never be the joy it should be.

That the people of the Scottish village rated this book is probably enough praise for you to buy and read it. And you will probably enjoy it. But in my opinion, The Siege of Krishnapur is not in the same league as Salman Rushdie’s Midnight’s Children, or J.M. Coetzee’s Disgrace. It’s doesn’t even belong to the same universe.


6 out of 10